If you’ve been in facility management long enough, you’ve encountered a few of these problems before: variable speed pumps that run close to 100% much of the time; a chiller that labors with low Delta T; or, worst of all, complaints of hot and cold spots in occupied spaces. So, what do you do? Look at the pumps or the chiller or the fan coils, right? Chances are an individual component is not what’s causing these chronic problems. You’ve probably got an imbalanced system on your hands.
A building’s hydronic HVAC system is rarely just the sum of its parts. Yes, it comprises chillers, boilers, pumps, variable frequency drives (VFDs), air handling units (AHUs) and valves that create a loop through which water is circulated to control the building’s temperature and its occupants’ comfort. But none of those components operate in a vacuum. Each one has an effect not just on the component next to it but on every other one, regardless of how far they are from each other. In fact, the nodes furthest from each other may impact each other the most. Variable speed pumps, for example, can surrender much of their part-load efficiency if the wrong balancing valves are installed at the terminal units. Too often systems are designed and specified like each component is working independently. Consequently, building owners continue to install inefficient systems and then struggle to find lasting solutions to chronic problems like hot spots, high utility bills and constant maintenance calls.
Looking at the system as a whole and choosing components that are “synchronized,” on the other hand, enhances the efficiency of the entire loop. Pressure independent control valves (PICVs) installed at the AHUs tightly control the water temperature entering and exiting the unit’s coils, allowing the chiller’s oil-free variable speed compressor to work as efficiently as possible. VFDs on the pumps supply only as much water as is demanded to take advantage of part-load conditions to save energy. All the while, each component collects valuable data on energy usage, flow, pressure and temperature for the building management system to aggregate and use to make decisions about predictive maintenance, fault detection and comfort.
This type of a synchronized hydronic loop made of synergistic components ultimately offers solutions to three common problems associated with conventional hydronic HVAC systems:
- Occupant comfort
- Design efficiency vs. installed efficiency
- Degradation of efficiency over time
These problems are often symptoms of an unbalanced system but are frequently misdiagnosed as issues with individual components.
Precise comfort control
A traditional HVAC system is designed using manual balancing valves to provide proper flow to all coils during the hottest and coldest days of the year, which typically occur just 2% of the time. These balancing valves, however, possess a fixed orifice that remains in the same open position the other 98% of the time, allowing the system’s differential pressure to change, and thus flow to the coils to shift even as loads remain constant. Ideally, flow should vary only in response to changes in load. This improper flow at constant load creates a situation known as “hunting,” which causes inefficient heat transfer, spikes in chiller and pump energy consumption, dramatic swings in discharge temperatures and, ultimately, chronic hot and cold spots in the occupied space.
The Pressure Independent Control Valves (PICVs) in a synchronized hydronic loop, on the other hand, continuously adjust their Differential Pressure Orifice position in response to dynamic load conditions, maintaining consistent differential pressure across the valve. This means the flow into the coils only varies in response to changing loads, allowing for efficient heat transfer and precise comfort control in the occupied space.
Design efficiency in all load conditions
It’s easy to assume that achieving maximum efficiency in an HVAC system means sacrificing comfort. After all, conserving energy at home usually means turning up the thermostat past the point of comfort. When it comes to hydronic HVAC systems, however, comfort and efficiency are two sides of the same coin.
As the PICVs at the air handlers continuously adjust to current load conditions to optimize heat transfer and comfort, they’re also minimizing flow into the coils. This means the system is only heating, cooling and pumping as much water as is necessary to meet demand. A synchronized hydronic loop utilizes variable speed pumps and oil-free variable speed compressors to match the system’s energy consumption to that demand, allowing the system to achieve design efficiency in all load conditions.
Sustained efficiency over time
Regardless of where a system starts out, its efficiency will decline with time. Chillers with traditional compressors degrade at a faster rate, as oil from the chiller mixes with the refrigerant and contaminates the system. That could lead to an immediate efficiency decrease of 7%, eventually climbing to a peak of around 20-30% efficiency loss. However, a synchronized hydronic loop utilizes oil-free chillers, completely avoiding these issues. Instead of oil, these chillers use magnetic rotors to eliminate friction. This technology not only allows the system to maintain a high level of efficiency, but also significantly reduces maintenance costs.
Synchronizing your hydronic loop offers the opportunity to find solutions to many of the problems you’ve probably experienced with conventional hydronic systems. You should always look at your system as a whole, as opposed to selecting components individually, to maximize efficiency, decrease downtime and, ultimately, improve occupant comfort and the bottom line. The efficiency of each component in the synchronized hydronic loop is superior to the efficiency of that same component in a system without the other components. In this way, the synchronized hydronic loop is truly greater than the sum of its parts.